The Premise
"Long Shot" is a 40-minute Netflix documentary from 2017, directed by Jacob LaMendola. It opens on Juan Catalan, a machine-shop worker in East LA, sitting across from the filmmakers and calmly explaining how he came to be charged with a murder he didn't commit. The setup is straightforward: a young woman is killed in the San Fernando Valley in 2003, detectives lock onto Catalan based on a witness composite, and prosecutors go for the death penalty. Catalan tells his lawyer, Todd Melnik, that he was at a Dodgers game that night with his little daughter. Melnik, an obsessive, starts trying to prove it. That's the first act. The strange lever that eventually enters the story — a certain HBO comedy shooting at Dodger Stadium the same evening — is teased in the opening minutes and then earned across the runtime.
The Case For
It's disciplined. LaMendola treats a story that could easily balloon into a three-part streamer as a tight procedural, and the compression is the point. Catalan himself is a good talking-head subject: dry, unshowy, occasionally funny about the worst period of his life. Melnik is even better — a defense attorney who talks like a man who still can't believe what he had to do to save his client. The interviews with the LAPD detective who arrested Catalan are handled without editorializing; you get to sit with the discomfort. And the eventual Larry David connection, which the marketing gives away and which I won't spell out here, is deployed as craft, not gimmick: LaMendola sets up the mechanics of alibi evidence patiently enough that when the material arrives, it plays as a puzzle piece rather than a punchline.
The Case Against
It's slight. If you want the sprawl of "The Jinx" or the moral vertigo of "The Staircase," this isn't that. There's no formal invention, no reenactment flourish, no score doing heavy lifting. A few sequences lean on stock B-roll of LA at night that you've seen in every true-crime doc since 2015. And because the outcome is a matter of public record and the marketing tells you the hook, some viewers will feel the tension leak out early. It's a case study, not a mystery.
Who It's For, Who'll Bounce
Sticks with: people who liked the first "Making a Murderer" episode but wished the whole thing was that episode. Anyone who watches "60 Minutes" segments on YouTube. Curb fans curious about a piece of trivia from season four. Bounces: viewers who want the deep-dive miniseries treatment, anyone allergic to talking-head docs, people who need a villain and a body count.
The Ruling
WORTH IT is the honest read. This is a well-made short documentary that knows exactly what it is and gets off the stage on time. LaMendola isn't reaching for a thesis about the criminal-justice system; he lets Catalan and Melnik tell the story and trusts the audience to draw the obvious conclusion themselves. That's the opposite of a lecture — the theme lives inside the events, not on top of them. Forty minutes, a clean structure, two strong subjects, one hell of a coincidence used with restraint. The genre rewards economy, and this one has it.
Sources: