The Drop
Netflix

Spartacus

WORTH IT

Operatic gore and a 1:1 sex-to-blood ratio. Knew exactly what it was.

sentenced 2026-07-12 by the guide

The Premise

Starz's Spartacus, created by Steven S. DeKnight, ran from 2010 to 2013 and is now sitting on Netflix waiting to ruin your week. It opens with a Thracian auxiliary (Andy Whitfield in season one, Liam McIntyre after Whitfield's death from lymphoma) getting screwed over by a Roman commander, losing everything, and ending up in chains at a gladiator school in Capua. That school belongs to Batiatus (John Hannah) and his wife Lucretia (Lucy Lawless), a pair of grasping middle-tier Romans clawing at the ankles of the actual elite. Early episodes are the training pit, the politics of the ludus, and the first bouts in the arena. Slow-motion arterial spray. Full-frontal everything. Latinate cursing you'll be quoting by episode four.

The Case For

John Hannah is the show. He plays Batiatus like a Shakespearean weasel with a coke problem, spitting insults in that Glaswegian-flavored pseudo-Roman dialect the writers invented ("gratitude," "apologies," no contractions, everyone sounds like a knife). Lucy Lawless matches him beat for beat. The 300-style bloodshed sounds tacky on paper and mostly is, but the choreography inside the arena is genuinely thought through — every fight has a plan, a counter, and a reason it goes the way it does. Manu Bennett as Crixus and Peter Mensah as Doctore give the training-yard scenes real weight. And DeKnight's writers understand serialized structure. Nothing sits still. Alliances rot inside three episodes. The pilot's a little wobbly; episodes three through six are where the hooks go in.

The Case Against

The CGI blood looks like cranberry juice thrown at a green screen, and it never stops looking that way. The dialect takes a full season to stop sounding ridiculous. The pilot leans hard on abs, sand, and howling, and if that first hour doesn't sell you the world, you won't make it to the good stuff. There's also a lot of it — nudity and gore played for spectacle, not always for meaning. If you need your prestige TV to be tasteful, this is the wrong island.

Who It's For, Who'll Bounce

For: anyone who liked Rome, Gladiator, or Game of Thrones for the palace-intrigue-plus-swords cocktail and isn't squeamish. If Vikings worked for you, this works harder. Against: people who found 300 exhausting after twenty minutes, anyone who watches TV with their parents, and viewers who need a hero who isn't constantly covered in someone else's insides. Episode two is the filter. Stay through it and you're in for the duration.

The Ruling

WORTH IT because the show is doing exactly what it set out to do, and doing it with real craft underneath the pulp. The pacing is disciplined. The performances from Hannah and Lawless are better than the genre asks for. The arena work is choreographed, not chopped together. It never lectures — it's a story about slavery and Roman rot that lets the cruelty of the system emerge from character and scene rather than pausing so someone can explain the theme. That's the whole trick. Ambitious trash executed with skill beats tasteful mediocrity every time. Watch it.

The People’s Line

THE PEOPLE CONCUR — NO OBJECTIONS FILED

One email. Every Friday.

Stop watching slop.

Free forever. Unsubscribe in one click. We'll never sell your email to anyone, mostly because we don't know how.