The Premise
Three middle-aged Englishmen drive expensive and/or barely-functional cars across places that don't want them there, then argue about it. That's the show. Jeremy Clarkson, Richard Hammond, and James May defected from the BBC's Top Gear in 2015 after Clarkson punched a producer over a cold steak, and Amazon threw them a reported small fortune to keep doing the same thing on Prime Video. It ran from 2016 to 2024, first as a weekly studio-plus-films format and then, from Series 4 onward, as feature-length travel specials. The Madagascar one, officially titled "A Massive Hunt," sends them to the island with a Bentley Continental, a Ford Focus RS, and a Caterham on a treasure-hunt pretext nobody really cares about. What they're really doing is trying to survive Route Nationale 5, routinely called one of the worst roads on earth.
The Case For
The specials are the reason to be here, and Madagascar is one of the good ones. Producer Andy Wilman shoots this like a proper travelogue: drone photography that puts most nature documentaries to bed, wide lenses on landscapes you've never seen on television, and a willingness to let a shot breathe. The three-way chemistry is 22 years deep and it shows, in the way only long friendships bicker. Clarkson blusters, May pedants, Hammond crashes. When one of the cars inevitably falls apart on a road that's more suggestion than surface, the panic is real because the situation is real. Nothing here is green-screen.
The Case Against
The scripted framing device (the "massive hunt" of the title) is a hat on a hat and everyone including the presenters knows it. Some bits land with a thud, particularly the studio-adjacent gags that were funnier in 2004. If you find Clarkson's public persona insufferable off-screen, two hours of him on-screen won't fix that. And there's a repetition problem across the specials generally: car breaks, one of them shouts, sunset, cut to camp. Once you've seen four of these, you've seen the rhythm.
Who It's For, Who'll Bounce
If you liked old Top Gear, you already know. If you've ever watched an Anthony Bourdain episode for the scenery and the banter more than the food, this is that with worse table manners. Fans of Long Way Round or any competent BBC travel doc will find plenty to enjoy. People who need plot, arcs, or characters who grow will be checking their phones by minute twenty. Anyone allergic to loud British men making fun of each other's cars, faces, and life choices should pick literally anything else on Prime.
The Ruling
WORTH IT, not higher. The craft that earns it is genuine: the cinematography does actual work, the location production is expensive in the ways that matter, and the three leads have a rhythm you can't fake or cast for. What keeps it out of the top tier is that the format is a format. It's a hangout show dressed up as an adventure, and the adventure scaffolding creaks. No lecture problem to speak of; the show has opinions about cars and roads and that's about the extent of its worldview. It's not trying to say anything larger and doesn't pretend to. What it's trying to do, it does with real skill and a helicopter budget. Put it on, don't think too hard, watch a Bentley suffer.
Sources: