The Premise
Ricky Gervais wrote, directed, and stars in "After Life," a half-hour Netflix show about Tony, a small-town newspaper reporter whose wife has died of breast cancer. He decides the only reason not to kill himself is that he can now say whatever he wants to whoever he wants. That's the pitch. He wanders the fictional town of Tambury doing local-interest fluff pieces about people with weird collections, insulting his coworkers, feeding his dog, and rewatching old camcorder tapes of his wife. Kerry Godliman plays her in the tapes. Penelope Wilton, Ashley Jensen, David Bradley, Tom Basden, Diane Morgan, and Tony Way round out a very good bench. Three seasons, six episodes each, 2019 through 2022.
The Case For
Gervais is doing something honest here that most grief shows can't manage: he treats depression like a condition his character actually has instead of a special-episode arc. Penelope Wilton, sitting on a bench in a graveyard, quietly steals the entire show every time she shows up. David Bradley as Tony's father in a care home is heartbreaking without being fussy about it. Diane Morgan gets some of the best throwaway lines on television. Ashley Jensen and Gervais have a lovely, low-key chemistry that never tips into rom-com. The Tambury exteriors, shot around Hemel Hempstead and Beaconsfield, give the whole thing a sleepy English-village texture that carries you through the episodes even when the writing is coasting. Half-hour installments, six per season, no cliffhangers. It's built for a Sunday.
The Case Against
Gervais the writer keeps handing Gervais the actor a soapbox, and Gervais the director keeps leaving the camera on it. Tony is regularly the smartest, kindest, most morally correct person in every scene, and side characters exist to either agree with him or be tidily corrected by him. The "I can say what I want" premise means a lot of scenes are just Gervais insulting a stock character (a fat postman, a dim colleague, a happy person) and then a piano cue tells you it was profound. The emotional beats are laid on with a trowel: soft piano, slow-mo, camcorder footage, voiceover of the dead wife telling him to be kind. By season three the show's out of moves and just repeats them louder.
Who It's For, Who'll Bounce
If you liked Gervais in "Derek" and don't mind him doing his own eulogy in real time, you'll be fine. Fans of gentle British comedies like "Detectorists" or "Doc Martin" will find a version of that with more swearing. If you found "Extras" or "The Office" bracing because Gervais played someone who was wrong, this one will grate — Tony is never wrong. Anyone allergic to sentimental piano scoring should quit at episode two.
The Ruling
BACKGROUND TV because the craft is real but the discipline isn't. The performances around Gervais are lovely, the runtime is merciful, and the Tambury atmosphere does a lot of quiet work. But the writing keeps stopping the show to deliver its thesis. Characters pause, the music swells, and Tony gets a small monologue about kindness or grief or the meaninglessness of everything, and then the plot resumes. That's the lecture problem in craft terms: the themes aren't emerging from what happens, they're being narrated over what happens. It's fine to have on. It's not something you sit up and watch.
Sources: